DERRIDA THE MOVIE
Over the next several years, Ziering Kofman shot Derrida "in indie film fashion -- i.e., whenever we had money" - in both Paris and the U.S. Then practical difficulties led her to consider seeking a co-director. "I'm an academic, so my hands-on knowledge of actual film production was, at the time, limited." In 1997, she attended a rough-cut screening of Kirby Dick's SICK: THE LIFE AND DEATH OF BOB FLANAGAN, SUPER MASOCHIST. "I was thrilled by Kirby's refusal to impose value judgments on the sexual preferences portrayed in that film. He wasn't stereotyping; he was open to respecting his subjects without hierarchizing their roles in the classic, static dominant/submissive positions. He was, for me, demonstrating in a way, a Derridean precept, one in which in any system of opposites it is difficult to entirely privilege one position over another." Dick was equally enthused by the footage Kofman had shot. "Looking at Amy's material, I was very struck by the unique and peculiar intimacy of what she'd been able to capture, as well as by Derrida's magnetic screen presence. I said to her: 'Well, you've got your star."
This charisma is something Derrida -- whose work is lionized in Europe has long preferred to shield from public view. "He once told us a funny story that we didn't have room for in the film," recalls Amy. "Up until sometime in the late 70's, I think, he not only had always refused to be filmed, but had, also, categorically refused to ever have his photograph taken. Even though by that time his work had become well established in Europe, most people still had no idea what he looked like. He had, and still has, a firm belief that the cult of personality is, to large degree, ridiculous. But then he started doing more political work, appearing at benefits for public causes. At one time the press was there, and they ended up running a picture of him in Le Monde - but they ran a photo of, I think, Michel Foucault, and erroneously identified it as 'Jacques Derrida.' Well, Jacques has this incredible power hair, and from that point on, realizing he couldn't control the inevitable, he rescinded his own strict media interdiction: 'Well, if they're going to print my picture anyways, it might as well be the right one!'"
This uneasiness with the media continues to this day. "This was the first documentary he consented to that actually got made. Given the seriousness of his work, and his own vigilance and pedagogical imperatives about respecting language, respecting words and the currency they carry, he reasonably fears the impossibility that his explorations could be translated into another medium with the same rigor and care. You can't just take an artist's paintings and transpose them into words. You can't just walk up to Einstein after he's talked about Relativity, and say to him: Hey. Could you explain that again, without all those formulas, so it makes sense? But people come to Jacques with just that misguided expectation. Just because his medium is language, it doesn't mean you can just 'get it' without doing considerable amounts of study, reading and preparation."
For Dick, one of the main attractions was exactly this - the project's seeming impossibility. "I've read a great deal of French theory, which exerted a powerful influence over my other work, especially SICK (1997). Like SICK, Derrida is not simply a straightforward presentation of a man and his work, but it is also an examination of the perpetual interplay between the two. With Derrida, however, the filmmaking challenge was much greater because his work isn't visual. But it was that challenge which drew me to the project a challenge I knew would compel me to come back at the material again and again, and eventually lead to my developing a form that could somehow interpret Derrida's thought in cinematic terms."
When production resumed, Dick and Ziering Kofman decided that Ziering Kofman should remain the primary interviewer, and together they composed the questions she would ask. Over the next two years, they shot Derrida on two different visits to the University of California at Irvine and also arranged to have overseas production crews cover Derrida's trip to Australia as well as his first trip to South Africa, where he gave a series of lectures on the subject of forgiveness. In early 2000, the production returned to Paris, to again cover Derrida's life there and to ask him to reflect on his theoretical and personal observations about the experience of being a subject of a film.
Dick began editing the film the following year, focusing on one of the central themes of the film that Derrida himself had raised: How does one reconcile a thinker's thought with their life? To entirely dismiss the relationship, as Heidegger does, is problematic -- as Derrida himself repeatedly points out. "The challenge, in editing these materials, was to let Derrida's life and thought resonate and interact without either being used to simply 'explain' the other." Including Derrida's playful shows of resistance, dodging questions, or repeatedly reminding the viewer of the artificiality of this or that circumstance in the interview, were essential in Dick's view: "These personal and playful asides are an important part of his thinking, and are found throughout his writing. Emphasizing these moments goes a long way toward countering the prejudice that Derrida is being difficult just to be difficult."
Dick chose to structure the film around excerpts from his work. "I wanted to convey the voice and rhythm of his writing, which is always different from than the way a writer speaks. This is especially true with Derrida, since in many ways the style of his writing is as radical and bracing as the content. Without getting a sense of that voice, one cannot really understand the ambition of his writing." Since one of the most prominent themes of the film, and of Derrida's writing, is that a philosopher's personal life is inevitably implicated in his or her own writing, Dick selected excerpts where Derrida reflects on that theme by writing about his position as writer or speaker, for example in the excerpt where he examines his own blindness to himself when he is improvising, or when he analyzes his position as subject at the very moment he is speaking with his dying mother.
Ziering Kofman agrees. "My strong suit was that I'd already studied with Derrida, already taught Derrida to students. I wasn't intimidated by the material, and had it in mind to make the film work on several levels. My hope was that the difficulty of his thought is not a put-off, but a central part of its appeal. The film is never didactic -- it tries to get you to do part of the work, which is what deconstruction is all about. If you come away from the film not "knowing" exactly what deconstruction is -- you've nevertheless been doing the work of deconstruction, simply by wrestling with the issues the film raises."
Adds Ziering Kofman: "Another attraction is the simple pleasure of having a historic cinematic record of such a person. Wouldn't it be interesting to be able to watch footage today of Plato, or Nietzsche during their lifetime? A hundred years from now, it will be just as remarkable and important to have a cinematic record of Derrida."
Kirby Dick -
Kirby Dick is an award-winning director whose last three films have premiered
in Documentary Competition at the Sundance Film Festival. In 1997, he directed
the internationally acclaimed SICK: THE LIFE AND DEATH OF BOB FLANAGAN, SUPERMASOCHIST,
which was released by Lion's Gate Films. SICK won the Special Jury Prize at
the 1997 Sundance Film Festival and the Best Feature Film Prize at the 1997
Los Angeles Independent Film Festival. It also earned a 1998 IFP/West Spirit
Award Nomination and an International Documentary Association Nomination for
Best Feature Documentary of 1998.
Dick's other films include CHAIN CAMERA, which received rave reviews during it's theatrical release and PRIVATE PRACTICES: THE STORY OF A SEX SURROGATE, awarded Best Documentary at the USA Film Festival. He also wrote the screenplay for GUY, which was produced by Polygram Pictures and starred Vincent D'Onofrio and Hopes Davis. Dick is currently completing a new documentary for HBO's prestigious "America Undercover" series.
Amy Ziering Kofman -
'Derrida' marks Amy Ziering Kofman's directing debut. Ms. Ziering Kofman studied
with Derrida in a doctoral program at Yale University in the 1980's. She most
recently produced the critically acclaimed feature documentary 'Taylor's Campaign',
which followed the race for a seat on the Santa Monica City Council by one of
its homeless residents.
PRODUCER
Amy Ziering Kofman
COMPOSER
Ryuichi Sakamoto -
Ryuichi Sakamoto is a world class composer whose score for Bertolucci's 'The
Last Emperor' won him an Oscar, a Grammy, a Golden Globe and the New York, Los
Angeles and British Film Critics Association awards for best original soundtrack.
Sakamoto has worked with numerous other noted directors, including Nagisa Oshima
(Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence, Ghotto,) Oliver Stone (Wild Palms), Pedro Almodovar
(High Heels), Brian De Palma (Snake Eyes), and for the BBC, John Maybury's 'Love
is the Devil'. Sakamoto has also collaborated artistically with David Bowie,
David Byrne, Iggy Pop, and Youssou N'dour, as well as writers William Burroughs
and William Gibson, and the performance artist Robert Wilson. Most recently,
he completed his second film with De Palma, composing the score for the upcoming
release 'Femme Fatale.'
EDITOR
Kirby Dick
Matt Clarke -
Matt Clarke most recently edited SHOWGIRLS: GLITZ AND ANGST for HBO's prestigious
America Undercover series. Prior to that, Clarke edited the critically acclaimed
CHAIN CAMERA, which premiered at the 2001 Sundance Film Festival. Clarke was
trained as an editor by the Academy Nominated Dody Dorn (MEMEMTO). He is currently
completing editing his third feature documentary for HBO entitled LIVING THROUGH
DYING.
ASSOCIATE PRODUCER
Gil Kofman
CAMERA
Kirsten Johnson -
Kirsten Johnson's camerawork is featured in three films at the 2002 Sundance
documentary competition: 'Derrida', 'American Stand-Off', 'The Two Towns of
Jasper'. Johnson most recently worked as director of photography on Gini Reticker
and Sandy McCleod's untitled documentary about a Ghanian recipient of political
asylum. Other work includes Raoul Peck's 'Whose Profit?' for ARTE, Barbara Koppel's
series on the Hamptons for ABC, and Katy Chevigny's 'Journey to the West' distributed
by Winstar. The documentary 'Innocent Until Proven Guilty' which she directed
in 1999, premiered at the Berlin Film Festival and was broadcast on HBO. She
is currently co-directing a documentary with Katy Chevigny on 'The Class of
'72' - the group of 588 prisoners who had their sentences commuted when the
death penalty was declared unconstitutional in 1972.
SOUND
Mark Z. Danielewski
Pascal Depres
Benoit Hillebrandt
ADDITIONAL CAMERA
Richard Atkinson
Baird Bryant
Christine Burrill
Herve Cohen
Mark Z. Danielewski
Gil Kofman
Arturo Smith
Geza Sinkovics
Chris Tetens
ADDITIONAL SOUND
Alan Barker
Kip Gynn
Yuri Racin
Chris Scarfile
ADDITIONAL EDITING
Gil Kofman
FIRST ASSISTANT EDITOR
Brian Jonason
ASSISTANT EDITORS
Mark Z. Danielewski
Adam Finberg
Annette Aryanpour
Damien Caldwell
EDITING CONSULTANT
Tristan Brighty
SUBTITLES
Amy Ziering Kofman
POST PRODUCTION SUPERVISOR
Brian Jonason
MUSIC MIXED BY
Ryuichi Sakamoto And Fernando Aponte
MUSIC RECORDED AT
Kab Studios NYC
MUSIC RECORDED BY
Fernando Aponte
RE-RECORDING MIXER
Mark Linden
TITLES
Mike Kahne
rom the Derrida the Movie website